Understanding more about the Florida Primary, and how it may pick the Next President

By Thunder Posted in Comments (15) / Email this page » / Leave a comment »

It looks like Florida voters will turn out in record numbers today (actually since voting started two weeks ago). This is driven partial to a state wide initiative to cut property taxes, and probably more by the Presidential primary.

With more than a million votes already cast during early voting or with absentee ballots, Florida should see turnout records fall today.

http://time-blog.com/real_clear_politics/2008/01/final_thoughts_on_flori...

Of the million voters that will have voted by the end of today, 500,000 will have been republican. Of that 500,000, 25% or 125,000 will have already voted before today. And as the Polls show, its too close to call. Two different polls have two different leaders.

Romney 34%, McCain 32%, Giuliani 13%, Huckabee 10%

U.S. Sen. John McCain, who had a 2% lead after polling Sunday night, now finds himself trailing former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney 34%-32% according to results of a telephone poll conducted Sunday and Monday nights January 27-28, 2008. Rudy Giuliani, who was tied with Mike Huckabee at 12%, has now taken a 3% lead over Huckabee (13%-10%). Ron Paul has 3%, and 7% are undecided..

“This is basically a dead heat. Romney gained a point since last night while McCain dropped 3%. A major change came from those who have already voted. On Sunday night, Romney and McCain were tied among the 33% who said they already voted. After Monday night’s polling, Romney had a 9% lead among those voters. Romney also cut McCain’s lead among those who say they will be “definitely voting” from 4% in Sunday’s polling to 2% at the end of polling on Monday night,” Steve Mitchell, president of Mitchell Interactive said.

Hours before the start of Florida's voting, Arizona Sen. John McCain held a slim 4-point lead over former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, 35 percent to 31 percent, in what was essentially a two-man race, the poll found.

http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN2428418520080129

To fully understand Florida, you have to realize that this is a very big state with a much different sets of population groups.

Florida has as many as eight [Regions]…
The Panhandle is home to a significant number of veterans. …more than one in five voters are military veterans… northern-most part of the state is seen as the most Southern part of Florida. John McCain and Mitt Romney will compete for votes there.


On the east side of the state… Romney will have to battle Mike Huckabee for social conservative votes… If Romney scores a big win along the coast, he could be in strong position around the rest of the state.
On the east side, the region around Daytona Beach and … retirees have flocked there, and Giuliani has spent time courting their votes.


On the west side of the central region, Tampa Bay, home to the second-largest media market in Florida, also has its share of retirees…Without a big pro-Giuliani turnout throughout the central part of the state, the former New York Mayor is going to leave Florida empty-handed. Pasco County, just north of Tampa Bay, takes pride in reporting their vote counts early. If Giuliani is to have success among the retirees on whom he has focused, early results should show a big pro-Rudy edge.
Giuliani will also need a big boost from the Treasure Coast, an area on the state's southeastern edge including Vero Beach, Port St. Lucie and Palm Beach… the area is home to the state's large Jewish community. Giuliani, insiders say, should be able to count on a boost there, as well.


More retirees populate Sarasota, Bradenton, Fort Myers and Naples, on the opposite coast… come largely from the Midwest as opposed to the Northeast. They are economic conservatives, setting up another battleground between Romney and McCain.
Miami-Dade County and Broward County each have huge Cuban populations, which traditionally vote Republican...

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/politics_nation/2008/01/geographic_coal...

Other factors in the race will be organization. In this case, its Romney’s organization which is basically Jeb Bush’s organization versus Charlie Crist’s Organization that McCain got when Charlie Christ endorsed him.
http://www.gwu.edu/~action/2008/romney/romneyorgfl.html

Finally, there is the ballet initiative which will cut property taxes. This is likely to bring out more Economic Conservatives.

The battle in Florida is a microcosm for the rest of the country. It is basically moderates verses conservatives. Its Voters who view Defense more important verses Voters who feel economic interest are more important. Its also the first primary where only registered republicans can vote. It’s the endorsement of a Governor who has been in office for less than a year, plus a US Senator versus Talk Radio host like Rush Limbaugh and Shawn Hannity.

Momentum has also effected Florida. Out of the three most hotly contested Primaries/caucus, three leaders emerged. Huckabee (Iowa), McCain(New Hampshire), and Romney(Michigan).

McCain took out Huckabee in South Carolina but Romney was able to negate that by winning little contested Nevada. While it was not hotly contested, it was well covered because of the democrats in Nevada. Romney was also able to emerge with the most delegates.

The winner of Florida will stand alone as far as momentum goes, and it will be hard to stop that train.

What will be the final out come. Well, If I knew, I would be hired by every news agency in the country. I am pulling for Romney, so I have rose colored glasses on.

The effect of what happens in Florida is easier to predict.

If McCain wins

It means that McCain may very well take NY and NJ. It also means that McCain will have the delegate edge. It also will have tremendous effect on California. It means that McCain will be seen as the candidate to beat and he should come out of Super Tuesday with the delegate lead.

Rudy will be on life support or completely out.
Romney will be playing catch up. He will not be out because he has a lot of support in the west and has a bank account. But he will trail badly in the delegate count.
Huckabee will be the least effected. Although he will fight McCain more for southern primaries. Still, Huckabee’s best chance is to be McCain’s running mate.

If Romney wins

It means that Romney will steam roll in the west, in particular California, where McCain and Romney are battling it out. It will also help Romney in the Mid west, and will mean that Romney will emerge from Super Tuesday with the delegate lead.
Rudy Regains his lead in NY and NJ and will still be a player. He will be behind the delegate count, but still have enough to influence the end result.
McCain will begin to decline and it very well may be the end of McCain.
Huckabee will pick up more southern delegates but without McCain, it doesn’t look like he is going anywhere. Still he will have a sizeable delegate count, and may yet have an influence in the end result.

After Florida voting is finished, Florida may very well be deciding who the next president is. As for me, I am going to Romney’s rally tonight to either celebrate a victory or the agony of defeat.

Let's use Mr. Occam. The winner of Florida will be an overwhelming favorite to win the nomination.

If McCain wins, he can bank winner take all victories in NY, NJ, AZ, and DE before the week of campaigning begins . That means he can fight Romney everywhere else, grab at least a few more states, and be the overwhelming delegate leader as of 2/6. Because Huckabee also will win some delegates and maybe even some states, Romney would wake up on 2/6 having to run the table in all the remaining primaries to win the nomination. Remember, Romney cannot win a brokered convention because the two other candidates with significant delegates can't stand him. The pressure on Romney to fold his campaign at this point would be immense.

If Romney wins, he will take everything except NY, NJ, and AZ, on February 5. Then the pressure on McCain to concede, financial and political, will be overwhelming.

Okay, show me any spin in there. I tried hard not too. I think you say that every time.

Although he is ahead in all of the Super Tuesday states?

That isn't spin? Please.

"I believe in grace, because I have seen it. In peace, because I have felt it. In forgiveness, because I needed it."

-George W. Bush

And these will crumble if Romney wins. Just like Huckabee's support crumbled (except in the deep south) after losing South Carolina.

McCain poll numbers in these states only took off after he won South Carolina. If he loses Florida, they will recede again.

If you don't think so, then what do you think will happen?

McCain was ahead in California, New York, and New Jersey before South Carolina, not after. I think your Huckabee comment is valid, but that is because nobody saw him as the winner in the general election, where McCain is still seen as electable. A lot of establishment has united around McCain. Unless he loses big, he will continue to do well in Super Tuesday states, mostly because they are bluer states that Giuliani more than likely will not be competing in, wheter Mitt wins Florida or not. I do agree that a Mitt victory makes him more competitive in the west and especially California, but I don't think it will necessarily put him ahead in those states. His unfavorables with Republicans are still high.

"I believe in grace, because I have seen it. In peace, because I have felt it. In forgiveness, because I needed it."

-George W. Bush

And if you look at those same polls, Romney is starting to move up. So I don't think you can say anything about these states until after Florida. After all, if you look at the early polls, Rudy would be far ahead.

http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/2008/president/ca/california_rep...

The Florida winner is going to be in the driver seat, and a Romney win is a death blow to McCain. He just does not have the same cards in hand that Romney does to survive the loss. Especially if Rudy does well enough to win NY and NJ. Either way, I think the winner most likely wins this thing, so I hope Romney comes out on top.

Go ahead, make your jokes, Mr. Jokey... Joke-maker. But let me hit you with some knowledge. Quit now.

-White Goodman

You've got it backwards. If Romney loses, it'll be a serious, if not fatal blow to him. If McCain loses, it'll be a major setback, but it won't lose him the nomination.

You might be right if Romney wins by 10pts or something, but that won't happen. If Romney wins by 3% or something, there is no way that'll knock out McCain in all the other states.

John Bolton for President
"FEAR THE 'STACH!!!"

And what makes you think that a Romney loss is any worse than a McCain loss? The effect will be relavitive the same. Romney has a long of Strength in the west.

What states will Romney win on Super Tuesday if he loses? If McCain loses, he still is competitive in NY, CA, NJ, and CT.

"I believe in grace, because I have seen it. In peace, because I have felt it. In forgiveness, because I needed it."

-George W. Bush

This electibility thing is only a myth. Its used as talking point by McCainacts. People don't vote on electibility (at least not republicans), they vote for the candidate that matches their values.

I wish it were true what you said; but if it were, why would early primaries matter so much? Psychologically speaking, the bandwagon effect is real and it's why candidates always trump polls showing themselves as the front-runner and downplay those showing them behind.

This is true of Republicans as well as Democrats.

By "The west" you must mean "Utah and Idaho (and maybe New Mexico)" because he certainly doesn't have much in Arizona, Texas, California, Oregon, Washington, etc.

Anyhow, it'll be worse because, yet again, he's outspent McCain by more then 5/1 in Florida, and so far, in places he's spent lots of money, the only place he's won is Michigan, where his dad was governor. He got almost nothing for all his money in Iowa, New Hampshire, and finished and embarrassing 4th in South Carolina after spending a fair amount of money there.

John Bolton for President
"FEAR THE 'STACH!!!"

actually, it wouldn't surprise me to see Romney take Arizonza. And yes, I think he could take Washington and Oregon, also California, Montana, etc.

Texas isn't exaclty the west, and they don't vote on super tuesday.

since he has already won the the closed MSM caucus, beating Rudy because Rudy withdrew

 
Redstate Network Login:
(lost password?)


©2008 Eagle Publishing, Inc. All rights reserved. Legal, Copyright, and Terms of Service