Redstate

... about which Jimmy Carville complained last weekend on MTP. I assume Russert will try to discredit them, but he'll hopefully spell their names right.

I've heard that the Jeff Gerth and Don Van Natta, Jr., book, Her Way, is the superior book of the two. The authors say it isn't all anti-Hillary, however. And Media Matters has already started trashing it.

We've traded our National Sovereignty for cheap roofing and yardwork.

Isn't it more accurate to analyze the ideology of the specific writer in question, in this case Carl Bernstein, before labeling him a liberal because we brand the Newspaper as a whole with the same label?

Let's not forget that Judith Miller worked for the NY Times, and her work about WMD was a group of pro-war pieces that were later discredited.

Gerth, the author of the other Hillary book, spent a great deal of time trying to present Hillary as a Whitewater lawbreaker. This is not a liberal would do.

You commited the fallacy of division

The fallacy of Division is committed when a person infers that what is true of a whole must also be true of its constituents.

I made no claims about the book.

Judith Miller was a liberal reporter. You committed a fallacy by asserting that because she reported a certain way on an issue unrelated to ideology, she must not be a liberal. It is non sequitur.

If you were talking to Kyle, he said only that they were investigative reporters who worked for a liberal newspaper. He did not call the reporters themselves liberals. Kyle committed no fallacy.

You've apparently fallen for the fallacious liberal narrative about Judith Miller's work on Iraq and WMDs.

You are well aware that the New York Times published articles about Iraq's WMDs citing Clinton Administration officials that said virtually the same thing in 1998, 1999, 2000, right? Before Bush took the oath of office?

Clinton himself said, in 2003 on Larry King Live that when he left office there were weapons of mass destruction that still remained unaccounted for by the Hussein regime.

What I'm trying to say is that Judy Miller's reports were entirely consistent with almost a decade of reporting on the subject of Iraq, Saddam Hussein, terrorism and WMDs.

PS: Carl Bernstein is as liberal as the day is long. And considering that there are Kossacks who go into fits of rage at the mere mention of Hillary's name, the idea that a liberal would never try to torpedo Hillary Clinton's campaign is not quite so far fetched.

George W. Bush: He's A Folder ... Not A Fighter.

I have been saying for a while now, the very characteristics which make Bush a good leader in some things are the very things that make him terrible. Primarily his stubbornness. He will stick with bad people and failed plans until it becomes a disaster.

"Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty"
Kyle

off-beat comedy at its best!