Duke Prosecutor Moves to Drop Charges

too little too late

By streiff Posted in Comments (19) / Email this page » / Leave a comment »

WRAL-TV in Raleigh, NC is running a headline that Mike Nifong, the prosecutor in the Duke lacrosse rape case, has moved to drop rape charges against the three indicted players.

No details are available.

[UPDATE]:

Prosecutors dropped rape charges Friday against three Duke University lacrosse players accused of attacking a stripper at a team party, but the three still face kidnapping and sexual offense charges, a defense attorney said.

« Toward an Understanding of the Obamian LanguageComments (4) | Secretary Rumsfeld's "Farewell Message to the Troops"Comments (2) »
Duke Prosecutor Moves to Drop Charges 19 Comments (0 topical, 19 editorial, 0 hidden) Post a comment »

Rape charges are being dropped, kidnapping and a sex charge of some variety or another are still in place.
_______________________________
If "pro" is the opposite of "con", what is the opposite of "progress"?

...to get their honor and reputations back?

Will there be an official apology?

Madhouse Thought and The Minority Report

until these young men get their reputations back. They should sue the city and receive millions of dollars.

Envisioning when all that is Left is the Right.

That he could not be here today, that is. He'd be in North Carolina this minute, walking up the steps to where the defense's legal team are headquartered. One of them - the one most in tune with the esoteric undercurrents of his profession - would have picked up his psychic vibrations, and turn, not knowing why. And they would have all turned at his intake of breath, and they would all stand there, quietly, at Mr. Cochran. And he would have taken that moment to smile.

And they would all know; they would all know that there are times, God help you, when you need a Johnnie Cochran to walk into your law firm and lead you out to war. It's not a nice thought, and you might lose a friend or two over the implications of it, but none the less. There are situations where a moment may be defined by a man, and this moment is defined by Johnnie Cochran. There would have been movies made of this. Real ones, with triumphantly moving cello pieces at strategic moments. Homespun wisdom. Pounding gavels and misty morning vistas. The capstone of a career, remembered for always.

The first man or woman who broke the silence and shake Johnnie Cochran's hand would have been assured a partnership. Not by Cochran's doing, but by the very nature of narrative causality itself. These things happen when you are in a moment defined by a man.

But, alas, the man is dead.

The Fuzzy Puppy of the VRWC.

Perhaps because there were no details.


Evil men hide from the truth, but good men stand upon it.

What charges, if any, can be brought against Nifong? Anyone know?

The initial charges amount to slander, in my view. Unfortunately, I think justice can only be pursued in a civil court, not a criminal one. There should be some lost jobs as well, including anyone who tries to protect the guilty. A good old house cleaning.

It's clear that Nifong can't possibly meet the burden of proof on a rape charge. Maybe by scaling back the charges he hopes to lower the bar in terms of the facts he has to prove, and to possibly make irrelevant to the actual charges some of the indefensible games he has played in terms of hiding DNA results, etc.

Since he has left some charges in place, I doubt very much that this is an instance of his starting to do the right thing.

Reportedly, the "dancer" said she couldn't remember if she was gang raped.

So, Nifong is going to rely on her testimony to prove sexual assualt of some variety and "kidnapping".

I'm a guy. I've never been raped. I'm not sure I can imagine what it would be like. But I'm sure I could remember it.

This will never get to court in any form. Unfortunately, Nifong cannot be charged criminally, he and the city can be sued for malicious prosecution. They should go after the state to have the charges expunged so they can truthfully say they've never been arrested on a felony charge.

The $24 question is, when all the charges are dropped will the "dancer" be arrested for filing a false complaint?
_______________________________
If "pro" is the opposite of "con", what is the opposite of "progress"?

Just because you are a guy doesn't mean you can't be raped. Over at NewsMax, Susan Estrich had a rare coherent column in which she addresses the issue of male rape. It happens, and it seems there's a serial male rapist on the loose in Houston right now.

I could try to tie this back to Nifong, but I can't think of any way that wouldn't be patently offensive.

I know better - 20+ years of prison ministry. I specifically said "I haven't been raped".
_______________________________
If "pro" is the opposite of "con", what is the opposite of "progress"?

is that they can't be bothered with actually pursuing wrongdoers like Nifong after he eventually drops all charges, as even Jeffrey Toobin thinks might happen.

Like George Allen walked away from his Senate race before the military votes from overseas were counted. Now some harridan from FL-13 wants to have a new election and the Repubs will probably assume the position on that case as well.

Nifong should be pursued half as relentlessly as the Left pursues its perceived bete-noires." We realize that the Left generates a mass psychosis among its most feverish adherents and the Conservatives and Repubs don't want to mimic that pathological habit.

But the WSJ types have money and don't really care about justice. The small-business types aren't organized or perfervid enough. And the religious types who might have the fervour are paralyzed by Christian charity.

So who is the enforcer among the elements of the Right? Is there no penalty for attacking white ethnics and provoking the politics of envy?

The MSM enforces or cheerleads for the leftist quixotic crusades. The right yawns and turns away.

I forget the quote about when good men do nothing, but it is very dangerous to let racialist demagogues like Nifong walk without some penalty.

It might be Nifong, or the Prosecutor who attacked Tom Delay on charges with no evidence, or that old bastard Jim Garrison who ruined peoples lives by linking them, with no evidence, to the Kennedy assassination.

I believe we have given prosecutors way too much power and not enough accountability.

"Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty"
Kyle

And the former AG of Massachusetts (Harshberger?) who won all those spurious daycare child molestation charges in the 1980's. And Janet Reno who did similarly in Florida. Sad fact is that over-zealous prosecutors rarely get punished, and more often get rewarded with a higher office.

That some reliable cultural commentator like Juan Cole is taking note of this. Maybe Duke should ask Harry Belafonte to use his key to the city to lock Nifong in his own jail. Cole is talking a lot about "natural rights" these days over at his blog and quoting Jefferson like there was literally no tomorrow -- so far nobody has falsely accused him of anything. Think of it: Juan Cole could unlock the chapel at Duke and Nifong could enter, confess his multitude of sins on the Altar of Diversity, and then Harry Belafonte could mete out Social Justice by locking him in the hoosegow.

Then Harry could offer to give a big opening concert for the next Duke LAX game, and donate the proceeds to NCAA Division I.

As a Virginian who is in exile here in Durham, NC, I must tell you that this kind of criminal incompetence is par for the course here. From the school board (a little more tolerable now that Jackie Wagstaff is gone) to government contracts to payment of bills to the city council, Durham has a long and storied history of public servants who have thoroughly abused their power.

The only pressure that will be brought to bear on Nifong will be from places other than Durham. The black community here will remain solidly behind him, regardless of the facts of the case (Tawana Brwley, anyone) and he will add his name to the long list of idiots who have served Durham so well.

The most interesting media moment since Phil Donahue commented on his (failed) cable show, inre: the Washington Beltway sniper(s):

"When are we going to go catch this white guy?"

But nevermind that. What I'd really like to see over the next few weeks is a full accounting from the New York Times of how many articles they published about this case before and after the rape charges were dropped. Wait, wait: I can tell you -- now that the big charges have been dropped, it's no longer national news, and therefore...

Even the University president is bad mouthing the prosecution, after previously assuming his students must be guilty and taking it out on the whole lacrosse team. Accepting the possibility that a woman of color may have unfairly accused some white guys must be a bitter pill to swallow for a politically correct academic.

As for Nifong, it seems to me that even if his suppression of evidence doesn't constitute criminal obstruction of justice, it should at least get him disbarred. But I don't know what the N.C. bar association's ethical rules are - I suppose that a lawyers's organization might well operate as a mutual protection club.

 
Redstate Network Login:
(lost password?)


©2008 Eagle Publishing, Inc. All rights reserved. Legal, Copyright, and Terms of Service